Can AI be Creative?
Sora is dead. Is this a temporary setback on the road to AI dominance of creative fields, or is there something more fundamental at play? Can AI be creative at all?
The debate on this question usually centers on the quality of AI output in a vacuum, but if we take connection with an audience as a requirement, we must consider the supply and demand of "creative"1 work.
In this framing, AI artists face what I'll call the instant imitator trap: Any original AI work can be instantly replicated by other AIs, making audience recognition of the original impossible.

Footnotes
-
For simplicity I'll omit scare quotes from here on out, but note: I don't think AI can be an artist! ↩



